I am referring to what I'll call the "winter solstice defense." It goes something like this:
Christians stole Christmas from the pagans. It was originally a pagan holiday that had nothing to do with Jesus, and early Christians co-opted it as a way of stamping out paganism.I do not doubt the veracity of this whatsoever, but I am not sure how it is supposed to explain anything about why an atheist would celebrate Christmas. At best, it might explain why a pagan would celebrate Christmas.
If an atheist wants to celebrate Christmas, he or she should be able to do so guilt-free simply because he or she finds it enjoyable. Why are any other reasons needed?
Subscribe to Atheist Revolution