Subscribe to Atheist Revolution
Breaking free from irrational belief and opposing Christian extremism
February 27, 2005
Who has the Burden of Proof?
In Who has the Burden of Proof? Atheism vs. Theism, Austin Cline (About.com) provides an outstanding discussion of something every atheist (and every religious person) should understand. Atheism (i.e., no belief in gods) is the default position. This means that the burden of proof lies with the religious believer who claims that some sort of god exists. This claim requires considerable evidence if it is to be accepted. The second that the religious person insists that the atheist prove his/her lack of belief, he or she makes an error in reasoning.
Subscribe to Atheist Revolution
Subscribe to Atheist Revolution
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
LinkWithin
First let me say, I greatly admire you blog. It is definitely one of earnest truth seeking. I say this not as some off handed compliment but a sincere observation of your posts and thoughts. I did, however, want to comment on your "Who has the burden of proof?" post. I could not agree with you more that theists have the burden of proof in the "does God exist debate?" Are you suggesting that no proof exists for God? I have found that in my earnest search for answers, more proof exists in favor of God than against him. I would love to dialogue with you - not to convince you of my position - but to learn from yours.
ReplyDeleteLet me also add a disclaimer: I am aware of the common image of Christians and their hard-headness and to be honest often times mean spirited responses to those who disagree with them...I try my hardest to not portray what I believe in that light - since I am human I have to admit the possibility of temporary lapses...however I try to make those few and far between...and try to accompany them with sincere apologies. I have no desire to debate you...but a sincere desire to dialogue with you.
Humbly,
RD Reid
Athiests have the burden of proof. Take a real close look at creation from a sub atomic level.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your kind words, RD Reid. In answer to your question, I was suggesting that I do not believe theists as a group have offered compelling evidence for the existence of supernatural beings. I appreciate your willingness to open a dialogue, and I'd love to hear more about the kind of evidence you mentioned.
ReplyDelete